Bias, Myth, and Folklore in Historical Records

By Randy Salars

Every historical record was created by a human with perspectives, motivations, and blind spots. Recognizing bias, myth, and folklore in your sources doesn't invalidate them โ€” it helps you extract the truth that's actually there.


What Are the Different Types of Bias in Historical Records?

Selection Bias

The documents that survived aren't random โ€” they were preserved by the literate, the powerful, and the institutional. The perspectives of the poor, illiterate, and marginalized are systematically underrepresented.

Author Bias

Newspaper editors had political allegiances. Soldiers had pride. Government officials had constituents. Every author had a reason to emphasize some facts and minimize others.

Hindsight Bias

Accounts written after events often reorganize the narrative to make outcomes seem inevitable. Memoirs are particularly susceptible.

Cultural Bias

Assumptions about race, gender, class, and nationality permeate historical records. These biases are themselves informative โ€” but they distort the facts being reported.


When History Becomes Folklore

Folklore emerges when real events are retold, embellished, and simplified over time. The transformation often follows a pattern:

  1. 1. Real event occurs โ€” A robbery, a shipwreck, a wealthy individual dies
  2. 2. Contemporary accounts exist โ€” Newspaper reports, official records
  3. 3. Oral retelling begins โ€” Details simplify, drama increases
  4. 4. Written compilation โ€” A writer collects oral stories, adds narrative structure
  5. 5. Legend status โ€” The story is accepted as "folk history" without anyone checking the original sources

How This Positions Your Research

Understanding bias, myth, and folklore doesn't make you a skeptic โ€” it makes you a disciplined researcher. You can appreciate the story while simultaneously verifying the facts. This dual awareness is what separates professional treasure research from wishful thinking.


Research With Discipline, Not Wishful Thinking

The Treasure Hunter's Research Guide teaches you to evaluate sources critically while maintaining the curiosity that makes research exciting.

Get the Research Guide โ†’

Related Pages

Treasure Research Intelligence

Critical thinking, source evaluation, and disciplined research techniques.

We respect your privacy. Unsubscribe at any time.